Dorado Purple Heart: Difference between revisions

From PigBoats.COM
Created page
 
Minor rewrite
 
(4 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{#seo:|title=The USS Dorado Project - Case for the Purple Heart.|keywords=USS Dorado (SS-248), USS Dorado Purple Heart medal, WWII Purple Heart awards, US Navy submarine history}}
{{#seo:|description=The case for awarding the Purple Heart medal to the crew of USS Dorado.}}
<center>[[File:Dorado header Mk 2.jpg]]</center>
<center>[[File:Dorado header Mk 2.jpg]]</center>
<center>
<center>
{| class="wikitable"  
{| class="wikitable"  
|+ <span style="font-size: 20px">Page Listing</span>
|+  
|-
|-
|[[The USS Dorado Project|Main Page]] || [[Latest News|Latest News & Updates]] || [[Dorado (SS-248)|The Submarine]] || [[Dorado Crew|The Crew]] || [[Dorado Photographs|Photographs]] || [[Dorado Loss Scenario|The Loss Scenario]] || [[Dorado Martin PBM Mariner aircraft|The Aircraft]] || [[Dorado Purple Heart|Case for the Purple Heart]] || [[Dorado Myths|The Myths]] || [[Dorado documents list|Research Documents]]  
|[[The USS Dorado Project|Main Page]] || [[Latest News|Latest News & Updates]] || [[Dorado (SS-248)|The Submarine]] || [[Dorado Crew|The Crew]] || [[Dorado Photographs|Photographs]] || [[Dorado Loss Scenario|The Loss Scenario]] || [[Dorado Martin PBM Mariner aircraft|The Aircraft]] || [[Dorado Purple Heart|Case for the Purple Heart]] || [[Dorado Myths|The Myths]] || [[Dorado documents list|Research Documents]]  
Line 10: Line 13:


<center>[[File:Subs bottom line 2.jpg]]
<center>[[File:Subs bottom line 2.jpg]]
<br><br>
<div style="text-align: center;"><span style="color:#00008B"><big>Are you a Dorado family member and would like to be a signatory on a formal request to have the Purple Heart awarded to the entire crew? Send us an email here: [mailto:ussdoradoproject@gmail.com '''ussdoradoproject@gmail.com''']</big><br><br>


__TOC__</center>
<center>[[File:RWB Starbar ver 3.jpg|300px]]</center>
 
<br>
<div style="text-align: justify;"><span style="color:#00008B">One of the primary goals of The USS Dorado Project is to petition for an award of the [https://purpleheartfoundation.org/ '''Purple Heart medal'''] for all of Dorado's crew. We believe an administrative oversight occurred after the Dorado's loss and a determination concerning the award was left in a pending status during WWII due to uncertainty regarding the circumstances, and by the rapid draw down of the size of the Navy Department immediately following the war. Likely, the person(s) responsible for reviewing the case left government service and the case "fell between the cracks". Examination of German U-boat records months after the war further clarified the circumstances of Dorado's loss as a likely friendly fire incident, and contemporary precedent shows that her crew should have been awarded the Purple Heart. Yet a decision appears to have never been definitively made.


<div style="text-align: justify;"><span style="color:#000000">
However, two of Dorado's seventy-seven crew members (Signalman 1st Class Richard Becker and Fireman 1st Class Vernon Gardner) DID receive the Purple Heart. In 1946 and 1947, family members of Becker and Gardner, on their own accord, petitioned the Navy Department on their behalf. The written response by the Navy's Bureau of Personnel granted the Purple Heart to SM1c Becker and F1c Gardner without reservation and it clearly states they were both entitled to it. Yet, no further action was taken for the rest of the crew. The reason for this inaction is not clear, but it may have been simply a case of bureaucratic inertia.


<div style="text-align: justify;"><span style="color:#00008B">
We presented our case in Washington, D.C. in May of 2025 to Rear Admiral Samuel Cox (Ret.), the Director of the Naval History & Heritage Command (NHHC), and Dr. Alexis Catsambis, the head of the Underwater Archeology Branch (UAB), and they have agreed to provide assistance and oversight in this matter. We would like it to be clear that The USS Dorado Project is a private organization and does not in any way represent the U.S. Navy, the NHHC, or any other government entity.


<center>[[File:RWB Starbar ver 3.jpg|300px]]</center>
We are currently (summer of 2025) in the process of drafting a formal letter to the [https://www.secnav.navy.mil/Pages/default.aspx '''Office of the Secretary of the Navy'''] Awards Board petitioning for an assessment to be made in this matter. We believe that it would add impetus and strength to our letter if we can garner the support and endorsement of as many close relatives as possible. Spouses, siblings and children are ideal, however grandchildren, nieces and nephews are also deeply appreciated. If you are a family member of a Dorado crewman and would like to be a signatory for this letter, please email us at the email address listed below to dialogue further. The case for correcting this unfortunate oversight is laid out in detail in the video below by Project Manager Thaddeus Weaver. Please watch and offer your thoughts. Thank you.<br><br>


[[File:RWB Starbar ver 2.jpg|left|70px]][[File:RWB Starbar ver 2.jpg|right|70px]]
{{#ev:youtube|id=Y2SvxnAbt4Q|alignment=center|dimensions=600x400}}
<br><br>
<center>[[File:Subs bottom line 2.jpg]]
<center>[[File:Subs bottom line 2.jpg]]
Page created by:<br>
Page created by:<br>

Latest revision as of 22:18, 12 July 2025


Main Page Latest News & Updates The Submarine The Crew Photographs The Loss Scenario The Aircraft Case for the Purple Heart The Myths Research Documents



Are you a Dorado family member and would like to be a signatory on a formal request to have the Purple Heart awarded to the entire crew? Send us an email here: ussdoradoproject@gmail.com


One of the primary goals of The USS Dorado Project is to petition for an award of the Purple Heart medal for all of Dorado's crew. We believe an administrative oversight occurred after the Dorado's loss and a determination concerning the award was left in a pending status during WWII due to uncertainty regarding the circumstances, and by the rapid draw down of the size of the Navy Department immediately following the war. Likely, the person(s) responsible for reviewing the case left government service and the case "fell between the cracks". Examination of German U-boat records months after the war further clarified the circumstances of Dorado's loss as a likely friendly fire incident, and contemporary precedent shows that her crew should have been awarded the Purple Heart. Yet a decision appears to have never been definitively made.

However, two of Dorado's seventy-seven crew members (Signalman 1st Class Richard Becker and Fireman 1st Class Vernon Gardner) DID receive the Purple Heart. In 1946 and 1947, family members of Becker and Gardner, on their own accord, petitioned the Navy Department on their behalf. The written response by the Navy's Bureau of Personnel granted the Purple Heart to SM1c Becker and F1c Gardner without reservation and it clearly states they were both entitled to it. Yet, no further action was taken for the rest of the crew. The reason for this inaction is not clear, but it may have been simply a case of bureaucratic inertia.

We presented our case in Washington, D.C. in May of 2025 to Rear Admiral Samuel Cox (Ret.), the Director of the Naval History & Heritage Command (NHHC), and Dr. Alexis Catsambis, the head of the Underwater Archeology Branch (UAB), and they have agreed to provide assistance and oversight in this matter. We would like it to be clear that The USS Dorado Project is a private organization and does not in any way represent the U.S. Navy, the NHHC, or any other government entity.

We are currently (summer of 2025) in the process of drafting a formal letter to the Office of the Secretary of the Navy Awards Board petitioning for an assessment to be made in this matter. We believe that it would add impetus and strength to our letter if we can garner the support and endorsement of as many close relatives as possible. Spouses, siblings and children are ideal, however grandchildren, nieces and nephews are also deeply appreciated. If you are a family member of a Dorado crewman and would like to be a signatory for this letter, please email us at the email address listed below to dialogue further. The case for correcting this unfortunate oversight is laid out in detail in the video below by Project Manager Thaddeus Weaver. Please watch and offer your thoughts. Thank you.



Page created by:
Thaddeus Weaver & David Johnston
©2025 - Thaddeus Weaver & PigBoats.COM
West Warwick, RI, Norfolk, VA
ussdoradoproject@gmail.com